CrownForge Energy
CrownForge Insights

The Achilles Heel

Market Intelligence3 min read

Key Extract

WTI fell 13% to $90.83, but US diesel inventories dropped below 100 million barrels as strikes on Iran resumed. Russian diesel shipments and Gulf tanker risks reveal the Achilles heel of energy sanctions: fuel still needs a buyer—and a ship.

Quick network update: Ian sat down with Jordan Frey, a prominent plastic surgeon to discuss oil and gas investing specifically for physicians and surgeons. For a recording of the webinar, you can find the latest link for it on our Media page.  Next, a bit of relief for the consumer first...

WTI fell from $104.12 to $90.83, and Brent fell by about the same share, the biggest weekly percentage loss since 2022. Traders sold on the midterm results and on talk of a deal with Iran.

But here's what happened.

IRAN

The US struck Iran twice last week.

On Monday, the day before the midterms, US forces hit targets near Qeshm Island in the Strait of Hormuz. US officials called them defensive strikes. On Friday, the US hit Iranian air defenses on Qeshm. Iranian state media said its army shot down a US drone. The US has not confirmed that.

Interestingly, before Monday, the Pentagon hadn't disclosed a strike on Iran since early September.

Now queue up the war rhetoric:

Thursday, Trump said the US may have to "destroy" the rest of Iran. Pentagon officials told the New York Times that forces on more than a dozen ships are ready to resume major combat. Iran's supreme leader warned of a "geographically unrestricted response."

The world doesn't see these as one-off strikes; more as the start of another round.

Qatar's prime minister is at the White House today with Iran's proposal: the US ends its blockade and lifts some sanctions, and Iran reopens Hormuz. US and Gulf officials doubt a deal is near.

Meanwhile, Iran keeps attacking tankers in the Gulf, and the Houthis keep hitting Saudi Arabia.

NOW THE ACHILLES HEEL...SO YOU KNOW WHAT'S ACTUALLY IMPORTANT TO NATIONS.

In October, Trump struck a deal with Putin to bring Russian diesel to the US, and Treasury authorized US companies to buy it despite the sanctions.

The diesel never arrived. At least three tankers headed for the US turned around because buyers feared legal action under the import ban Congress passed. One went toward Brazil, and another went into the Mediterranean.

The diesel still sold, just somewhere else.

That's the Achilles heel. When fuel gets short enough, governments will buy from countries they're sanctioning. The barrels always find a buyer, and the only question is who.

Gulf crude is finding buyers too. Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Iraq and Kuwait shipped 15.53 million barrels a day in October. A good question is how they are getting through, because tankers are getting struck harder and more frequently by Iran. Let's hope it's not a short sighted gamble to fill crude/distillate demand today, at the risk of permanently losing tankers.

Without tankers, surplus supplies don't matter.

THE TANK

Crude found a way around the strait. Diesel hasn't.

US distillate stocks fell 3.6 million barrels to 99.3 million, the first reading under 100 million since May 2003. Analysts polled by Reuters expected a draw of 100,000 barrels.

Commercial crude fell for a fifth straight week, and the SPR slipped again to 282.2 million barrels.

US output hit a record 14 million barrels a day. The rig count rose by one, to 604.

Why should you care?

The price fell 13% in a week. The tanks kept draining despite more crude supposedly coming out, and the strikes resumed.

Not a good sign...

Last week's numbers
MetricValueNote
WTI$90.83Nov 6 settle, down from $104.12
Brent$98.32Nov 6 settle, January contract
Diesel (retail)$6.292/galDown from $6.352
Commercial crude409.8M bblDown 0.9M, a fifth consecutive decline, 4% below the five-year average
Distillates99.3M bblDown 3.6M, about 13% below the five-year average, the lowest since May 2003
SPR282.2M bblDown 0.4M
US crude production14.0M b/dA record
US rig count604Up 1; 463 oil rigs

Source: EnergyNow, EIA, Baker Hughes

It's veterans day on Wednesday, a salute to all veterans out there. What we hope for at CrownForge, is to put less of them in harm's way.

Your Oil and Gas team,

CrownForge Energy team